It is necessary to say a few words to explain this book. The original title of the book was "Musings on Woman and Labor."
It is, what its name implies, a collection of musings on some of the points connected with woman's work.
In my early youth I began to write a book on Woman. I continued the work till ten years ago. It necessarily touched on most matters in which sex has a part, however incompletely.
It began by tracing the differences of sex function to their earliest appearances in life; not only as when in the animal world two ameboid globules coalesce, and the process of sexual generation almost unconsciously begins, but to its yet more primitive manifestations in plant life. In the first three chapters I traced, as far as I was able, the evolution of sex in the different branches of non-human life. Many large facts surprised me in following this line of thought by their bearing on the whole modern sex problem. Such facts as this, that in the great majority of species on the earth the female form exceeds the male in size and strength and often in predatory instinct; and that sex relationships may assume almost any form on earth as the conditions of life vary; and that, even in their sexual relation towards offspring, those differences which we, conventionally, are apt to suppose are inherent in the paternal or the maternal sex form, are not inherent - as when one studies the lives of certain toads, where the female deposits her eggs in cavities on the back of the male, where the eggs are preserved and hatched; or, of certain sea animals, in which the male carries the young about with him and rears them in a pouch formed of his own substance; and countless other such. Above all, this important fact, which had first impressed me when as a child I wandered alone in the African bush, and watched cock-o-veets singing their inter-knit love-songs, and small singing birds building their nests together, and caring for and watching over, not only their young, but each other, and which has powerfully influenced all I have thought and felt on sex matters since; - the fact that along the line of bird life and among certain of its species sex has attained its highest and esthetic, and one might almost say intellectual, development on earth: a point of development to which no human race as a whole has yet reached, and which represents the realization of the highest sexual ideal which haunts humanity.
When I had ended these three chapters I went on to deal as far as I was able with woman's condition in the most primitive, the savage and semi-savage states. I had always been strangely interested in watching the condition of the native African women in the primitive society about me. When I was eighteen I had once a conversation with a Kafir woman still in her untouched primitive condition, a conversation which made a more profound impression on my mind than any but one other incident connected with the position of woman has ever done. She was a woman whom I cannot think of otherwise than as a woman of genius. In language more eloquent and intense than I have ever heard from the lips of any other woman, she painted the condition of the women of her race; the labor of women, the anguish of woman as she grew older, and the limitations of her life closed in about her, her sufferings under the condition of polygamy and subjection; all this she painted with a passion and intensity I have not known equaled; and yet, and this was the interesting point, when I went on to question her, combined with a deep and almost fierce bitterness against life and the unseen powers which had shaped woman and her conditions as they were, there was not one word of bitterness against the individual man, nor any will or intention to revolt; rather, there was a stern and almost majestic attitude of acceptance of the inevitable; life and the conditions of her race being what they were. It was this conversation which first forced upon me the fact, which I have since come to regard as almost axiomatic, that the women of no race or class will ever rise in revolt or attempt to bring about a revolutionary readjustment of their relation to their society, however intense their suffering and however clear their perception of it, while the welfare and persistence of their society requires their submission: that, wherever there is a general attempt on the part of the women of any society to readjust their position in it, a close analysis will always show that the changed or changing conditions of that society have made woman's acquiescence no longer necessary or desirable.
Another point which it was attempted adequately to deal with in this division of the book was the probability, amounting almost to a certainty, that women's physical suffering and weakness in childbirth and certain other directions was the price which woman has been compelled to pay for the passing of the race from the quadrupedal and four-handed state to the erect, which was essential if humanity as we know it was to exist (this of course was dealt with by a close physiological study of women's structure); and also to deal with the highly probable, though unproved and perhaps unprovable, suggestion that it was mainly the necessity which woman was under of bearing her helpless young in her arms while procuring food for them and herself, and of carrying them when escaping from enemies, that led to the entirely erect position being forced on developing humanity.
These and many other points throwing an interesting light on the later development of women (such as the relation between agriculture and the subjection of women) were gone into in this division of the book dealing with primitive and semi-barbarous womanhood.
When this division was ended, I had them typewritten and with the first three chapters bound in one volume about the year 1888, and then went on to work at the last division, which I had already begun.
In this I went on to deal with what is more popularly known as the women's question: with the causes which in modern European societies are leading women to attempt readjustment in their relation to their social organism; with the direction in which such readjustments are taking place; and with the results which in the future it appears likely such readjustments will produce.
After eleven years, 1899, I had finished these chapters, and had them bound in a large volume with the first two divisions. There then only remained to revise the book and write a preface. In addition to the prose argument I had in each chapter one or more allegories; because while it is easy clearly to express abstract thoughts in argumentative prose, whatever emotion those thoughts awaken I have not felt myself able adequately to express except in the other form. [The allegory "Three Dreams in a Desert" which I published about nineteen years ago was taken from this book; and I have felt that perhaps being taken from its context it was not quite clear to every one.] And I had also tried throughout to illustrate the subject with exactly those particular facts in the animal and human world, with which I had come into personal contact, and which had helped to form the conclusions which were given, as it has always seemed to me that in dealing with sociological questions a knowledge of the exact way in which a writer has arrived at his view is necessary in measuring its worth. The work had occupied a large part of my life, and I had hoped, whatever its deficiencies, that it might at least stimulate other minds, perhaps more happily situated, to an enlarged study of the question.
In 1899 I was living in Johannesburg, when, owing to ill-health, I was ordered suddenly to spend some time at a lower level. At the end of two months the Boer War broke out. Two days after war was proclaimed I arrived at De Aar on my way back to the Transvaal; but martial law had already been proclaimed there, and the military authorities refused to allow me to return to my home in the Transvaal and sent me down to the Colony; nor was I allowed to send any communication through, to any person who might have extended some care over my possessions. Some eight months after, when the British troops had taken and entered Johannesburg, a friend, who, being on the British side, had been allowed to go up, wrote me that he had visited my house and found it looted and that all that was of value had been taken or destroyed; my desk had been forced open and broken up, and its contents set on fire in the center of the room, so that the roof was blackened over the pile of burnt papers. He added that there was little in the remnants of paper of which I could make any use, but that he had gathered and stored the fragments till such time as I might be allowed to come and see them. I thus knew my book had been destroyed
Some months later in the war when confined in a little up-country hamlet many hundreds of miles from the coast and from Johannesburg; with the brunt of the war at that time breaking round us, de Wet was said to have crossed the Orange River and to have been within a few miles of us, and the British columns moved hither and thither. I was living in a little house on the outskirts of the village, in a single room, with a stretcher and two packing-cases as furniture, and with only my little dog for company. Thirty-six armed African natives were set to guard night and day at the doors and windows of the house; and I was only allowed to go out during certain hours in the middle of the day to fetch water from the fountain in the middle of the village, or to buy what I needed. I was allowed to receive no newspapers or magazines.
A high barbed wire fence, guarded by armed natives, surrounded the village, through which it would have been death to try to escape. All day the pom-poms from the armored trains that paraded on the railway line nine miles distant could be heard at intervals; and at night there was the talk of the armed natives as they pressed against the windows, and the tramp of the watch with the endless "Who goes there?" as they walked round the wire fence through the long, dark hours when I was neither allowed to light a candle nor strike a match. When a conflict was fought near by, the dying and wounded were brought in; three men belonging to our little village were led out to execution; death sentences were read in our little marketplace; our prison was filled with our fellow-countrymen; and we did not know from hour to hour what the next would bring to us.
Under these conditions I felt it necessary I should resolutely force my thought at times from the horror of the world around me, to dwell on some abstract question, and it was under these circumstances that this little book was written, being a remembrance mainly drawn from one chapter of the larger book. The armed native guards standing against the windows, it was impossible to open the shutters, and the room was therefore so dark that even the physical act of writing was difficult.
A year and a half after, when the war was over and peace had been proclaimed for about four months, I with difficulty obtained a permit to visit the Transvaal. I found among the burnt fragments the leathern back of my book intact, but the front half of the leaves had been completely burnt away; the back half of the leaves next to the cover were still all there, but so browned and scorched with the flames that they broke as you touched them; and there was nothing left but to destroy it. I even then had a hope that at some future time I might yet rewrite the whole book. But life is short; and I have found that not only shall I never rewrite the book, but I shall not have the health even to fill out and harmonize this little remembrance from it.
It is with some pain that I give out this fragment. I am only comforted by the thought that perhaps all sincere and earnest search after truth, even where it fails to reach it, yet often comes so near to it that other minds more happily situated may be led, by pointing out its very limitations, to obtain a larger view.
I have dared to give this long and uninteresting explanation, not at all because I have wished, by giving the conditions under which it was written, to make excuse for any repetitions or lack of literary polish in the book, for these things matter very little; but because (and this matters very much) it might lead to misconception on the subject-matter itself if its genesis were not understood.
Not only is it not a general view of the whole vast body of phenomena connected with woman's position, but it is not even a bird's-eye view of the whole question of woman's relation to labor.
In the original book the matter of the parasitism of woman filled only one chapter out of twelve, and it was mainly from this chapter that this book was drawn. The question of the parasitism of woman is, I think, very vital, very important; it explains many phenomena which nothing else explains; and it will be of increasing importance. But for the moment there are other aspects of woman's relation to labor practically quite as pressing. In the large book I had devoted one whole chapter to an examination of the work woman has done and still does in the modern world, and the gigantic evils which arise from the fact that her labor, especially domestic labor, often the most wearisome and unending known to any section of the human race, is not adequately recognized or recompensed. Especially on this point I have feared this book might lead to a misconception of the great insistence on the problem of sex parasitism, and the lighter dealing with other aspects lead to the impression that woman's domestic labor at the present day (something quite distinct from, though indirectly connected with, the sexual relation between man and woman) should not be highly and most highly recognized and recompensed. I believe it will be in the future, and then when woman gives up her independent field of labor for domestic or marital duty of any kind, she will not receive her share of the earnings of the man as a more or less eleemosynary benefaction, placing her in a position of subjection, but an equal share, as the fair division, in an equal partnership. [It may be objected that where a man and woman have valued each other sufficiently to select one another from all other humans for a life-long physical union, it is an impertinence to suppose there could be any necessity to adjust economic relations. In love there is no first nor last! And that the desire of each must be to excel the other in service. That this should be so is true; that it is so now, in the case of union between two perfectly morally developed humans, is also true; and that this condition may in a distant future be almost universal is certainly true. But dealing with this matter as a practical question to-day, we have to consider not what should be, or what may be, but what, given traditions and institutions of our societies, is, to-day.] Especially I have feared that the points dealt with in this little book, taken apart from other aspects of the question, might lead to the conception that it was intended to express the thought that it was possible or desirable that woman in addition to her child-bearing should take from man all his share in the support and care of his offspring and of any woman who fulfilled with regard to himself domestic duties of any kind. In the chapter in the original book devoted to man's labor in connection with woman and with his offspring more than one hundred pages were devoted in illustrating how essential to the humanizing and civilizing of man, and therefore of the whole race, was an increased sense of sexual and parental responsibility, and an increased justice towards woman as a domestic laborer. In the last half of the same chapter I dealt at great length with what seems to me the most pressing of practical sex questions at this moment - man's attitude towards those women who are not engaged in domestic labor. That vast and always increasing body of women, who as modern conditions develop are thrown out into the stream of modern economic life to sustain themselves and often others by their own labor; and who yet are bound hand and foot, not by the intellectual or physical limitations of their nature, but by artificial constrictions and conventions, the remnants of a past condition of society. It is largely this maladjustment, which, wisely studied in all its ramifications, will be found to lie as the taproot and central source of one of the most terrible social diseases that afflict us.
The fact that for equal work equally well performed by a man and by a woman, it is ordained that the woman on the ground of her sex alone shall receive less recompense, is the nearest approach to a wilful and unqualified "wrong" in the whole relation of woman to society to-day. That males of enlighterunent and equity can for an hour tolerate the existence of this inequality has always seemed to me almost incomprehensible; and it is only explainable when one regards it as a result of the blinding effects of custom and habit. Personally 1 have always felt so profoundly on this subject, that this and one other matter connected with woman's sexual relation to man are the only points connected with woman's position in thinking of which I have always felt it necessary to crush down indignation and almost fiercely to restrain it, if I should maintain impartiality of outlook. I should therefore much regret if the passing manner in which this question has been touched on in this little book made it seem of less vital importance than I hold it.
In the last chapter of the original book, the longest, and to me the most important, I dealt with the problems connected with marriage and the personal relations of men and women in the modern world. In it I tried to give expression to what I believe to be a great truth, and one on which I should not fear to challenge the verdict of long future generations -- that the direction in which the endeavor of woman to readjust herself to the new conditions of life is leading to-day is not towards a greater sexual laxity or promiscuity or an increased self-indulgence, but toward a higher appreciation of the sacredness of all sex relations, and a clearer perception of the sex relation between man and woman as the basis of human society, on whose integrity, beauty, and healthfulness depend the health and beauty of human life, as a whole. Above all, that it will lead to a closer, more permanent, more emotionally and intellectually complete relation between the individual man and woman. And if in the present disco-ordinate transitional stage of our social growth it is found necessary to allow of readjustment by means of divorce, it will not be because such readjustments will be regarded lightly, but rather as when, in a complex and delicate mechanism moved by a central spring, we allow in the structure for the readjustment and regulation of that spring, because on its absolute perfection of action depends the movement of the whole mechanism.
In the last pages of the book, I tried to express what seems to me a profound truth often overlooked. That as humanity and human societies pass on slowly from their present barbarous and semi-savage condition in matters of sex into a higher, it will be found, that over and above its function in producing and sending onward the physical stream of life (a function which humanity shares with the most lowly animal and vegetable forms of life, and which even by some noted thinkers of the present day seems to be regarded as its only possible function), that sex and the sexual relation between man and woman have distinct esthetic, intellectual, and spiritual functions and ends, apart entirely from physical reproduction. That noble as is the function of the physical reproduction of humanity by the union of man and woman, rightly viewed, that union has in it latent, other, and even higher forms of creative energy and life-dispensing power, and that its history on earth has only begun. As the first wild rose which hung from its stem with its center of stamens and pistils and its single whorl of pale petals had only begun its course, and was destined, as the ages passed, to develop more and more, stamen upon stamen to develop into petal upon petal, and to assume a hundred forms of joy and beauty.
And it would almost seem, that, on the path toward the higher development of sexual life on earth, as man has so often led in other paths, that here it is perhaps woman, by reason of those very sexual conditions which in the past have crushed and trammeled her, who is bound to lead the way, and man to follow. So that it may be that at last, sexual love that tired angel who through the ages has presided over the march of humanity, with distraught eyes, with feather-shafts broken, and white wings drabbled in the mires of lust and greed, his golden locks caked over with the dust of injustice and oppression-till those looking at him have sometimes cried in terror, "He is the Evil and not the Good of life!" and have sought, if it were possible, to exterminate him - shall yet, at last, with eyes bathed from the mire and dust in the stream of friendship and freedom, leap upwards, his white wings spread, resplendent in the sunshine of a distant future - the essentially Good and Beautiful of human existence.
I have given this long and wearisome explanation of the scope and origin of this little book because I feel that it might lead to grave misunderstanding were it not understood how it came to be written.
I have inscribed it to my friend, Lady Constance Lytton; not because I think it worthy of her, nor because of the splendid part she has played in the struggle of the women fighting to-day in England for certain forms of freedom for all women. It is, if I may be allowed without violating the sanctity of a close personal friendship so to say, because she, with one or two other men and women I have known, have embodied for me the highest ideal of human nature, in which intellectual power and strength of will are combined with an infinite tenderness and wide human sympathy, a combination which, whether in the person of the man or the woman, is essential to the existence of the fully rounded and harmonized human creature; and which an English woman of genius summed in one line when she cried in her invocation of her great French sister:-
"Thou large-brained woman and large-hearted man!"
One word more I should like to add, as I may not again speak or write on this subject. I should like to say to the men and women of the generations which will come after us -"You will look back at us with astonishment! You will wonder at passionate struggles that accomplished so little; at the, to you, obvious paths to attain our ends which we did not take; at the intolerable evils before which it will seem to you we sat down passive; at the great truths staring us in the face, which we failed to see; at the truths we grasped at, but could never get our fingers quite round. You will marvel at the labor that ended in so little; - but, what you will never know is how it was thinking of you and for you, that we struggled as we did and accomplished the little which we have done; that it was in the thought of your larger realization and fuller life that we found consolation for the futilities of our own."
"All I aspire to be, and was not, comforts me."
Proceed to Chapter 1.
Return to Table of Contents
Return to Main Page